• Login
  • Register

Work for a Member company and need a Member Portal account? Register here with your company email address.

Article

Debunking the Princess Leia lie

By Kate Repantis

Like many alumni, Daniel Smalley ’05, MEng ’06, SM ’08, PhD ’13 is a Star Warsenthusiast. But when he watches the first episode in the Star Wars series, Smalley is academically miffed.

In the movie, R2-D2 delivers a seemingly holographic yet also 3-D message from Princess Leia pleading for Obi-Wan Kenobi’s help. “There’s a violation of physics here,” Smalley says.

“The way we interpret that movie scene is, R2-D2 is creating an image in space that can be seen from every angle, just like a real physical object,” he explains. “A real physical object shoots [light] photons in all directions.” But the Princess Leia message is not real—she’s a display created by light, which travels in a straight line. In reality, the princess would only be seen by the film’s other characters if they stared at her from the exact same direction—down the barrel of R2-D2’s projector.

Spurred on by this and further pop culture slights to physics, like that of Iron Man’s gauntlet, which appears in both 3-D and holographic form (“It almost ruined the movie for me,” he remembers), Smalley formed the Electro-Holography Research Group as a new professor at Brigham Young University after graduating from MIT.

Related Content