Human Dynamics team tops Fragile Families Challenge


The Fragile Families Challenge is a new scientific mass collaboration to improve the lives of disadvantaged children in the United States.

A team of researchers from the Human Dynamics research group at the MIT Media Lab has won first place in three categories in the Fragile Families Challenge (FFC). The contest is based on the Fragile Families and Child Wellbeing Study, which followed thousands of American families for more than 15 years, collecting information about the children, their parents, their schools, and their overall environments.

FFC participants were challenged to use this info in a new way: With all the background data from birth to age nine, as well as some training data from age 15, how well could they predict six key outcomes in the following categories?:

  • GPA (academic achievement) of the children
  • Grit (passion and perseverance) of the children
  • Material hardship of the household (a measure of extreme poverty)
  • Eviction of the families (for not paying the rent or mortgage)
  • Layoff of the caregiver
  • Job training (if the primary caregiver would participate in a job skills program)

Computation-plus-social science approach

More than 150 teams from around the world submitted over 3,000 predictive models. The Lab’s Human Dynamics team, under the supervision of the group’s director Alex "Sandy" Pentland, is the only one to win in more than a single category: It ranked first in predicting GPA, grit, and layoff; 2nd in job training, 8th in material hardship, and 10th in the eviction category. “The fact that the Human Dynamics gang did such a super job is a testimony to the antidisciplinary, computation-plus-social science approach we take,” says Pentland. He adds that “it shows the potential for this sort of computational social science to help forge a brighter future for underprivileged kids.”

Led by graduate student Abdullah Almaatouq, the team also included Eaman Jahani, Daniel Rigobon, Yoshihiko Suhara, Khaled Al-Ghoneim, Abdulla Alhajri, Abdulaziz Alghunaim, and Alfredo Morales-Guzman. They used ensemble methods in machine learning, combined with information theoretic approaches and substantive knowledge of social science, to produce their winning model.

Expanding the range of social science

Almaatouq says that his team’s entry, along with many others submitted to the Challenge, can offer a new way to improve surveys in the future and expand the range of social science theories. “Also, these submissions can highlight potential targets for policy intervention in efforts to improve the lives of disadvantaged children in the US. For example, I learned through the Challenge that eviction is a natural target for policy intervention, but it has been challenging to pinpoint the causal impacts of eviction on children." As part of their prize,  the team will speak at the Fragile Families Challenge scientific workshop, which will take place in mid-November at Princeton University, where the Challenge is based at the Bendheim-Thoman Center for Research on Child Wellbeing.

“We were very impressed with the contribution that Abdullah and his colleagues made to the Fragile Families Challenge,” says Matthew J. Salganik, a professor in Princeton’s department of sociology and a co-organizer of the FCC. “They were able to combine ideas from social science and data science in a new way, and the resulting performance was amazing. My colleagues and I are very excited for them to present their approach at our upcoming scientific workshop.”

Mass collaboration

In an interview when the FFC launched in March this year another FFC organizer, Ian Lundberg, explained that “the central goal is to use machine learning methods for mass collaboration in the service of qualitative interviews.” Lundberg, a graduate student in the Princeton University Office of Population Research, noted that “by combining ideas from social science and data science, we can—together—help address important scientific and social problems. And, we expect that through a mass collaboration we will accomplish things that none of us could accomplish individually. This project will demonstrate a new way of doing scientific research.”

“The challenge doesn't end here for us,” says Almaatouq. He and his fellow researchers will submit a paper on their winning FFC model for a special issue of Socius, the open access journal published by the American Sociological Association, they’ll also contribute as co-authors to the collective paper on the overall results of the Fragile Families Challenge. The Human Dynamics team also plans to use the data from the Fragile Families and Child Wellbeing Study for future research and to further investigate the limits of predictability of its outcomes.

Related Content